> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://aftermath.site/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# 500 Finger Fillet Wants You To Gamble (Your Fingers) On Pain
- URL: https://aftermath.site/500-finger-fillet-review-impressions/
- Published: 2026-11-19T18:13:03.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T18:13:03.000Z
- Description: 500 Finger Fillet explores what you're willing to risk, and what you're willing to endure
- Author: Harper Jay MacIntyre
- Tags: Video Games, 500 finger fillet, Freelance, Impressions, review

By the time I accidentally cut off my third finger, I had a sickening thought. *Maybe this will make things easier; maybe this is actually a valid strategy.* A reasonable person might give up at this point, but I’m a sicko. I wanted to keep playing. Because no one is making me do this but myself.

This is what happens when you play [*500 Finger Fillet*](https://store.steampowered.com/app/4602120/500%5FFINGER%5FFILLET/?ref=aftermath.site) by DEADBODY Games. The concept is simple: you are strapped to a device and need to play Five Finger Fillet (aka the “knife game”) until you’ve managed five hundred stabs of the knife. There are ten rounds, fifty stabs each, and a clock running down all the while. That’s tense enough already, but there’s a small roguelite element on top. Each round, you pick your knife—they vary in size and special effects—and from time to time you can buy items in a shop. After all, why not spice up the dismemberment?

What follows is complicated to say the least. Not the stabbing! That’s pretty simple: hit the button and the knife will drop. Usually, you want to avoid stabbing your fingers. Then again, if I select the scalpel, I won’t accrue any pain points and risk passing out if I stab myself. To top it off, there’s only a 15% chance of slicing your entire finger off. That’s not bad.Besides, when you really think about it, aren't your fingers just another resource you can spend?

This is obviously all fictional, but maybe I’m okay hurting myself if the circumstances are right. *500 Finger Fillet* isn’t just about what you’re willing to risk; it’s an exploration of what you are willing to endure. There’s a dark little video game within that framework, but there’s also an exploration of gambling, titillation, and consent.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/30/f5/30f5b1bb-84ee-4c26-b446-fb9a5e512994/content/images/2026/11/data-src-image-0734407e-791f-4edb-ad04-2404fc07c83c.jpeg)

500 Finger Fillet

The answer comes when you run out of time. The entire affair is witnessed by a bear puppet. When the time runs out, another one of the puppeteer’s hands reaches out. For a moment, it seems like they will strangle you. Instead, they reach down and gently caress your hand, unlocking the stabbing device. “Same time tomorrow?” they ask. 

You might be forgiven for thinking *500 Finger Fillet* is a kind of horror game when you boot it up. The grindhouse off-kilteredness seems dangerous. But these few seconds reframe the entire experience as a mutually agreed upon arrangement. I am not a hostage; I am a participant.

Games allow us to experience not only the fantasy of being a hero; they can allow us to explore fraught and complex circumstances that might be too dangerous to try in the real world. Much like how booting up *Ladykiller in a Bind* might [give a player a safe introduction to BDSM](https://kotaku.com/a-bdsm-game-that-let-me-explore-a-new-type-of-sexual-ex-1788189623?ref=aftermath.site), a session of *500 Finger Fillet* provides more than a roguelike. In buying this game and playing it, I have willingly entered into an arrangement with the developers: I give them five dollars, and in exchange I get thrills. It’s not kink, although I suppose it could be for another player. Even so, what might have been torture is reframed as a consentual exploration. This is a sensory experience both within the fiction of the game and in real life. 

This play-acting raises questions. I gave you $250, would you let me play the knife game with you in real life? Is that enough incentive for you to place your hand on the table and stay still as I stab around you?

I’m going to guess that many of you would say, “lmao fuck that.”

What if I gave you $1000 dollars to do it to *me*? I’ll even sign a piece of paper, a proper contract, saying that I won’t hold you liable for any harm that happens. You could cut me, nick me, pierce me, or remove a part of me. I give you my consent. I’m paying you money. 

I suspect that more of you might be willing to do that. *That* is what *500 Finger Fillet* is exploring. In the game, the player’s body can be reframed in a variety of ways. To a player seeking an optimal run, fingers and flesh are resources. One way to lose time in *500 Finger Fillet* is to cause too much pain to yourself; pass a threshold and you’ll pass out, losing time. 

What if there was a knife that took off 50% of your pain if you stabbed yourself twice? Suddenly, there’s incentive to stab yourself. Losing a finger in this circumstance isn’t only bad for the obvious reasons–without one more finger on the table, you have less meat to stab and less chances to reduce that pain score. Playing those odds is exciting! There is a sick thrill in understanding your flesh as something that can be made utile. *500 Finger Fillet*’s system of upgrades and items encourage this kind of gambling. How common is a 15% chance really?

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/30/f5/30f5b1bb-84ee-4c26-b446-fb9a5e512994/content/images/2026/11/data-src-image-b83fb281-5f9d-4136-9967-589b2b61d99b.jpeg)

Unfair Flips

Last year, DEADBODY Games member Heather Flowers released [*Unfair Flips*](https://store.steampowered.com/app/3925760/Unfair%5FFlips/?ref=aftermath.site). It’s a simple game with one goal: flip a coin and have it land on heads ten times in a row. The starting flip is “unfair” at only 20% chance of getting heads. There’s ways to increase those odds, but even at pure 50/50 coin tosses, the odds of flipping heads ten times in a row are 1/1024\. But as you play, you begin to lie to yourself about the numbers. I’ve hit heads eight times in a row! Surely, I’ll get to nine. Odds don’t work like that.

*500 Finger Fillet* also plays with our perceptions of chance and percentage. In one round, I chose an upgrade that reduced the rate of pain I’d take per stab by 25%. In exchange, there was a 3% chance the machine jams. That’s tiny! Until you only have a few seconds on the clock to make your last stabs of the round. Lemme tell you, when that happens, I’m pretty sure 3% is actually 100% because damn it man why now?!

Many of *500 Finger Fillet*’s best upgrades take the form of rings. These grant all kinds of bonuses, from extra money per miss to a steady supply of blood (too many severed fingers means you risk bleeding out), but these only apply if you have a finger to put the ring on. You start to juggle the numbers. Okay, I get a special item if I stab myself three times, but I have a 16% chance of dismemberment and a lot of good rings. Do I risk it?

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/30/f5/30f5b1bb-84ee-4c26-b446-fb9a5e512994/content/images/2026/11/data-src-image-5145b886-d656-4c1d-9663-6c91ad30a8de.jpeg)

500 Finger Fillet

These number games bring out further excitement. Beyond limbs, what are you willing to gamble? At one point are the odds no longer acceptable? If 15% is acceptable; what about that screwdriver with the 16% odds on cutting off your finger? These aren’t questions you’d want to consider in real life, but in a video game we can grapple with them, chew on them. We allow ourselves to risk it.

The game asks you a question between rounds: “Why are you doing this?”

There’s many different answers. I am doing it because I want to support small game developers. I am doing it because I want to understand why this stark violence is allowed on Steam while [games about sex are scrutinized](https://aftermath.site/steam-censorship-future-no-thanks-perfect-tides/). I am doing this because I want to write an article about it and make money. I want my five dollars worth. I want to explore my limits. I want a safe space where I can ask what I’m willing to lose. I want to have fun. I am doing it because I like it.

This isn’t torture. It’s expression and exploration. Every tremble of the knife, every jam in the machine, captures my full attention. Each new variable and fresh percentage adds spice to the arrangement. I have a lot of reasons for doing this. It’s also very important to me that you understand that it is my *choice* to be here. Here, in this place, I can bleed safely.

### Recommended

[Thanks/No Thanks For Telling Me About Buckshot Roulette, EveryoneAre games that send up gambling \*really\* sending it up?![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/30/f5/30f5b1bb-84ee-4c26-b446-fb9a5e512994/content/images/icon/favicon4-dbf526f6-1a87-4519-b722-f556eb5a1010.png)AftermathRiley MacLeod![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/30/f5/30f5b1bb-84ee-4c26-b446-fb9a5e512994/content/images/thumbnail/bucks-05bc560b-21d1-4b3c-be5e-936cc61c051e.jpg)](https://aftermath.site/buckshot-roulette-cloverpit/)