Skip to content

Between GTA VI’s Release, Tribunal’s End, And Union Vote, Rockstar Workers Confront Life-Changing Week

'We have had no indication that layoffs are coming, but it’s hard not to worry about what the future holds'

Between GTA VI’s Release, Tribunal’s End, And Union Vote, Rockstar Workers Confront Life-Changing Week
IWGB
Published:

It’s a pivotal week for workers at Rockstar, and not just because Grand Theft Auto VI is finally, after all these years, actually coming out. 

The massively-anticipated (and just plain massive) crime caper’s launch coincides with two events that could permanently alter the course of work culture at Rockstar: the conclusion of a UK tribunal to determine whether or not 31 workers were unjustly fired last year as a result of organizing activity in conjunction with Independent Workers' Union of Great Britain (IWGB) and—tied closely to that—a recently Rockstar-sanctioned union vote.

This week, both fired workers and Rockstar made their closing statements to the tribunal, with disagreements largely stemming from workers’ use of a Discord that they claim was private but which Rockstar has said constituted a security liability. From Richard O’Keefe and Lord John Hendy KC, who represented fired workers (as reported by This Week in Videogames):

O’Keefe said Rockstar management was aware of the union’s Discord group for three years, and that action was only taken against it when one of management’s “covert informants relayed that IWGB [membership] was approaching 10% member density within the workforce,” with the layoffs taking place shortly afterward.
O’Keefe then stated that managers directed the informant to collect “evidence of disparagement, breaches of information security and the presence of ex-employees in the server,” suggesting there was a “joint enterprise to dismiss IWGB activists.”
…
“[Workers] were not told the case against them. They were handed a letter which they had no time to read, which when read makes the most generalised allegations of gross misconduct […] with no particulars,” Lord Hendy KC continued. “No claimant reading his or her letter of dismissal would know what it is that he or she was alleged to have done wrong which had brought this fate upon their heads.”
He went on to claim that impacted staff were not given detailed charges identifying what they had done, disciplinary hearings, warnings about their conduct, or appeal hearings. 
“The effect of alleging gross misconduct was to deprive the claimants of payment in lieu of notice […] A point which is exacerbated by the fact that the stigma of being dismissed for gross misconduct inevitably meant that they would be impeded or prevented from finding alternative work.”
Lord Henry KC then stated that the dismissals were “devised as a tactic of shock and awe with three objects.”
The objects, he stated, included preventing “future trade union activity” by affected staff, to discourage “actual and prospective trade unionists from activity within the IWGB,” and to “prevent the IWGB [from] representing the employees, including the claimants through the process of collective bargaining.”

Rockstar, for its part, stuck to its guns, insisting that ex-employees had overstepped and endangered the secrets of a company that has weathered multiple high-profile leaks. From Rockstar lawyer Thomas Cordrey (as reported by This Week In Videogames):

[Cordrey] went on to say that [Rockstar head of publishing Jennifer] Kolbe assessed messages from the Discord group for misconduct, and that some showed “data security breaches” and “disparagement.” He cited messages calling managers “sneaky bastards,” messages saying that Grand Theft Auto VI was “not content complete,” and stated that 50% of the group were not union members, 10% “did not even work for [Rockstar],” and one member was a “hostile journalist.”
Cordrey stated that “blameworthy conduct” was the reason for the dismissals, and not unionisation efforts:
“We put it in the written submissions, by way of analogy, of a union member slapping a manager in the face. We said in that circumstance, it is not difficult to conclude it is the slap, and not the union membership, which explains the reason for the dismissal.”
In reference to the Discord messages, Cordrey later stated that it was “astonishing” that they sought to defend this kind of material.
“It is unclear on what planet employees thought they could denigrate and disparage their employer and their employers’ parent company in a semi-public environment without destroying trust and confidence, which is at the heart of employment relationships.”
“None of the claimants can come before you and say they didn’t have fair warning that their conduct was such that [it] would open them up to dismissal for gross misconduct,” he added. “They were in brazen breach of [confidentiality] provisions.” 

While everyone has now said their piece, the final judgement could still be a ways off. We might be looking at a wait of weeks or even months. 

"I cannot give a timeframe for producing the judgement in this case,” said Judge Lucy Wiseman (according to PMG’s Chris Bratt). “What I will say is that I will use my best endeavors to get that judgement out as quickly as I possibly can."

With GTA VI now being anointed as one of the best-reviewed games of all time, fired workers find themselves battling a surge of mixed emotions.

“‘No claimant reading his or her letter of dismissal would know what it is that he or she was alleged to have done wrong which had brought this fate upon their heads,’” ex-Rockstar UI developer Will Mesilane said on Bluesky, quoting fired workers’ representation. “My fate was having to leave the country and leaving our dogs behind.”

“I don't even know how to react to this,” Mesilane said in another post about GTA VI’s Metacritic score of 99. “Despite everything I moved across the world to work on this game, I still worked on it. This is a huge achievement for me and all my friends who were fired and those still there.”

A union, should enough workers vote in favor of it, could prevent up to 1,600 Rockstar employees from enduring similar indignities in the future. In a piece for The Guardian, Rockstar animation programmer and union representative Nestor Uriarte explained why it’s more crucial than ever that workers secure a union.

“After the big day [of GTA VI’s release], we have had no indication that layoffs are coming, but it’s hard not to worry about what the future holds,” Uriarte wrote. “Studios across the industry have been slashing huge portions of their workforces, with an estimated 24,000 roles axed globally over the last two years. It says a lot about the industry that even my colleagues and I, working on the biggest game of all time, are worried about getting laid off. But the truth is that workers across the sector are helpless to resist the waves of redundancies crashing around us, until we get organized.”

He also pointed to other concerns, like AI, and noted that workers should have a seat at the table in determining how new technologies will impact their day to day lives. 

The union voting period began on November 12 and concludes on November 26. It’s impossible to know which way the chips will fall, but Uriarte says that the union will have workers’ backs regardless.

“Whatever happens in this ballot, our union will continue fighting for a studio that works for every single person at Rockstar, and for workers across the industry,” he wrote. “Unionizing shouldn’t be something we simply admire from afar when dockers, miners or teachers do it. It’s something we can, and must, embrace for ourselves. The future of the industry shouldn’t be a game played over our heads.”

I Wish Rockstar Cared About People As Much As It Does GTA VI NPCs
You can't talk a big game about handcrafting everything while mistreating the people responsible
Nathan Grayson

Nathan Grayson

Co-owner of the good website Aftermath. Reporter interested in labor and livestreaming. Send tips to nathan@aftermath.site or nathangrayson.666 on Signal.

All articles

More in Labor

See all

More from Nathan Grayson

See all