Skip to Content
Video Games

2023 Game Of The Year Deathmatch: Final Fantasy XVI vs Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty

Welcome to our first human-on-human match!

Aftermath / Starline

The weekend was but a brief respite for our gladiators, as a new week--a new year, even--brings fresh mettle to be tested.

Last week we saw Pinocchio obliterate Elephant Mario in a walkover. Tonight's bout may be more evenly-matched, if only because this is the first time in the whole tournament that two human (well, close enough) beings have faced off.

If you're just joining us, or need a refresher after the weekend, here are the rules: there are 16 games in the mix for Game of the Year 2023. We're pitting them against each other in a knockout tournament. But we're not pitting the games themselves against each other; instead, we're selecting a Champion from in or around each game and having them duke it out in the arena in hand-to-hand (or weapon-to-weapon, or hand-to-weapon) combat. The winner, decided via a schoolyard "would Batman beat Superman" style debate, moves on. The loser does not. Here's how things stand after four bouts:

And now, to introduce our Champions for this evening's entertainment. Representing the Xbox 360 Era School Of Visual Design Presents: Final Fantasy XVI is protagonist Clive Rosfield, while fighting for the honour of Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty: World's Most Expensive Do-Over will be the actor Idris Elba.

Three, two, one...LET'S GO:

Nathan: Everyone thinks Clive's voice actor, Ben Starr, is hot, but they also think Idris Elba is hot. Have a feeling this is gonna be a close one.

Riley: Maybe it can just be a makeout contest?

Nathan: I'm not opposed to this!

Riley: Then WE'RE the winners.

Nathan: But how does one win a makeout contest?

Chris: Clive is hotter on principal because Idris Elba keeps getting cast in bad stuff.

His weakness is his agent.

Luke: Ben Starr was never the star of an NBA 2K storyline, which definitely counts in his favour.

Chris: I generally think an Eikon is stronger than any theoretical Sandevistan, but I admit that is a matter of debate.

Riley: I'm voting Idris Elba.

Gita: Clive can’t figure out if slavery is good or bad I’m giving this to Idris who isn’t a coward.

Luke: I'm going with Idris because, with the makeout contest ending in a tie, it comes down to a walk-off, and he's the best-dressed video game man of 2023.

Chris: True on both counts, also that jacket is incredible.

WINNER: IDRIS ELBA

Idris wins! Tune in tomorrow to see who he'll face in the quarter finals: it'll be the winner of the match between Armored Core VI and Hogwart's Legacy.

Enjoyed this article? Consider sharing it! New visitors get a few free articles before hitting the paywall, and your shares help more people discover Aftermath.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Aftermath

Despite What NYT, WaPo, And Vanity Fair Seem To Think, We Still Need Critics

"You’re ceding that process to people who do not have experience or training or standards"

Alien: Earth Has The Juice

I was skeptical, but Noah Hawley has not let me down yet.

August 15, 2025

What Cyberpunk 2077 Can Teach Real-World Cities

Night City's urban design highlights the problems, and solutions, real cities deal with around walkability, housing, and mixed-use areas

August 14, 2025

Stripe Says Support Team Reps Were ‘Totally Wrong’ About LGBTQ Content Ban

“Stripe has no prohibitions on the sale of LGBTQ+ content or goods"

From Nintendo Power Hotline To Now, Human Labor Has Always Been The Soul Of Video Game Guides

Despite its boosters' claims, AI will never be able to replace a human guides writer

I Broke My Foot But The iWalkFree Gave Me Mobility Back

Breaking your foot sucks, but the iWalkFree 3.0 gets you half way to walking again with some minor caveats.

August 13, 2025
See all posts